Why Hong Kong Wants to Be a Hub for the Crypto Sector

Hong Kong wants to become an international crypto hub even as jurisdictions like the US cast a wary eye on the sector. In June, a new licensing system kicked off to regulate crypto exchanges offering trading in tokens like Bitcoin and Ether. The regime is part of Hong Kong’s effort to attract fresh capital and talent back to the city, after its reputation was tarnished by years of harsh Covid-19 curbs and a crackdown on political dissent. Initial reaction was largely positive from digital-asset firms, but there was a lack of major investment pledges. Hong Kong’s push appears to have quiet backing from Beijing even as mainland China sticks with a ban on crypto trading

1. What are the regulations?

new rules mean that retail investors can trade coins on exchanges licensed by the city’s Securities and Futures Commission. Hong Kong says its approach is high on consumer protection, with strict criteria on which virtual assets can be bought and sold. Some of the factors that platforms must consider when deciding on tokens to offer include how long a coin has been in circulation, its market capitalization and average daily trading volume. The tokens must also be incorporated in at least two cryptocurrency indexes from prominent institutions, one with a background in traditional finance. In addition, the SFC mandates that crypto firms must put other safeguards in place before accepting customers, like assessing if users have essential knowledge of digital assets before investing, and setting trading or position limits “with reference to the client’s financial situation.” 

2. Why is Hong Kong embracing crypto?

Hong Kong’s policy pivot is part of a wider effort to restore the city’s credentials as a cutting-edge financial hub. It’s a reputation that was put at risk by years of strict Covid-19 restrictions and political unrest, which caused the economy to slow and talent to leave. Financial Secretary Paul Chan called cryptocurrencies and other virtual assets “unstoppable new financial innovations” at an event organized by the Hong Kong Association of Banks in November last year, and said there’s a “need to embrace them.” The government has allowed exchange-traded funds investing in CME Group Bitcoin and Ether futures, and sold its inaugural digital green bonds, which use digital ledgers to make the settlement and coupon payment process faster. 

3. Is this Hong Kong’s first foray into crypto? 

Hong Kong used to be a digital-asset center in earlier years before taking a more skeptical stance. Exchanges including FTX and CRYPTO.COM (previously known as Monaco) were founded in the city. Prior to the new regulatory regime, the SFC had a voluntary licensing program. Only two exchanges — OSL and HashKey — opted into that legacy framework, which permitted them to provide services solely to professional investors with portfolios of at least HK$8 million ($1 million). The rules came after mainland China told platforms to stop trading in cryptocurrencies and banned initial coin offerings, or ICOs, in 2017. The mainland barred crypto transactions and pledged to root out mining of digital assets in September 2021.

4. How significant is mainland China’s prohibition on crypto trading?

One possible risk is that China’s ban could spill over to semi-autonomous Hong Kong. However, Hong Kong regulators have pushed back against this idea, citing the “one country, two systems” principle that permits the former British colony to have its own economic and political system. There are also signs that Hong Kong’s approach could have tacit approval from Beijing. Representatives from China’s Liaison Office and other officials have been spotted at crypto gatherings in the city, according to people familiar with the matter, who also described the encounters as friendly. The low-key support may signal China is keen to use Hong Kong as a testing ground for digital assets. However, Beijing has not indicated any softening of its tight rein on the sector locally amid concern about consumer protection, the potential use of crypto to evade capital controls, and the environmental impact of power-hungry Bitcoin mining. 

5. What hurdles remain? 

A key issue for crypto firms is regulatory ambiguity. There are a number of areas not specifically addressed by the SFC. These include so-called “NewFi” categories like decentralized finance, derivatives and staking in respect to digital assets. NFTs and utility tokens such as those used for play-to-earn gaming also fall outside the scope of plainly regulated activities. Virtual asset firms operating in these areas need to determine whether their business offerings constitute securities and, if so, require a license. The task is complex and the SFC has indicated decisions will be made on a case-by-case basis. Other obstacles include banking access, as crypto firms face stringent know-your-customer and anti-money laundering rules. The SFC and Hong Kong Monetary Authorityurged lenders to support the sector, and held meetings in April and June to encourage lenders to open accounts for regulated crypto companies. Talent recruitment is another challenge. Responsible officers — who bear the primary responsibility for compliance at a licensed corporation — have been in short supply. Institutional-level crypto traders and developers are also frequently cited as difficult to find.

6. What has been the reception to Hong Kong’s crypto pivot?

Hong Kong’s crypto pivot sparked interest from local and foreign firms given the potential for the city to act as conduit for Chinese wealth if ever the mainland loosens its digital-asset curbs. Companies such as Huobi, OKX and Amber Group said they intended to pursue licenses but no big investment pledges immediately followed the roll out of the new regime. It’s unclear if the regulations are attractive enough to entice firms to invest heavily. The focus on retail-investor protection could dent profitability if areas like margin trading, staking and derivatives remain off-limits. In addition, the crypto market globally is yet to fully recover from its $1.5 trillion rout last year.  

The Reference Shelf

• The Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission’s homepage on the new rules
• Bloomberg Opinion’s Andy Mukherjee asks if crypto will ever be a safe investment
• More QuickTakes on why crypto needs on-ramps, why it matters if coins are called securities, and what’s happening with crypto in Europe
• Bloomberg Intelligence looks at Asian exchanges’ differing blockchain strategies
• Lots of cities want to become crypto hubs, including Miami, South Korea’s and Hong Kong rivals Singapore, all looking to snare crypto jobs
• Subscribe to the Bloomberg Crypto Newsletter.